| 1 | Lorraine Heath | Samantha and the Cowboy | |
| 2 | Beverly Jenkins | Belle and the Beau | |
| 3 | Kathryn Smith | Anna and the Duke | |
| 4 | Margaret Moore | Gwyneth and the Thief | |
| 5 | Meg Cabot | Nicola and the Viscount | |
| 6 | Karen Hawkins | Catherine and the Pirate | |
| 7 | Elaine Barbieri | Miranda and the Warrior | |
| 8 | May McGoldrick | Tess and the Highlander | |
| 9 | Kathryn Smith | Emily and the Scot | |
| 10 | Lorraine Heath | Amelia and the Outlaw | |
| 11 | Beverly Jenkins | Josephine and the Soldier | |
| 12 | Meg Cabot | Victoria and the Rogue |